Properties listed in Rentals

Compare properties

Cottage on Sunset

21
Comfortable and private, this is your home away from home on Kelleys Island. • ...
Comfortable and private, this is your home away from home on Kelleys Island. • 2 Bedrooms that sleep 6 very ...
member

Sandy Beach House

42.5
Lovingly restored century home with four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths promises to make your ...
Lovingly restored century home with four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths promises to make your island stay a memorable experience. Sandy ...

Stay on KI

100100
Website: stayonki.com Stayonki.com is a website dedicated to being the #1 resource for booking ...
Website: stayonki.com Stayonki.com is a website dedicated to being the #1 resource for booking accommodations on Kelleys Island. Our mission ...

Island Delight

22
Island Delight offers a relaxing, easy-living atmosphere for a maximum of four adult occupants, ...
Island Delight offers a relaxing, easy-living atmosphere for a maximum of four adult occupants, with the possible addition of a ...

Summer Wind

31.5
Private cottage comfortably decorated with a cathedral ceiling and bright, open floor plan. The ...
Private cottage comfortably decorated with a cathedral ceiling and bright, open floor plan. The home is located on a quiet, ...
member

Lakeshore Landing

32
Lakeshore landing is located on the south side of Kelleys Island just west of ...
Lakeshore landing is located on the south side of Kelleys Island just west of Seaway Marina. Kelleys is a picturesque ...
member

Memory Manor

32
Memory Manor is located in a very quiet neighborhood approximately 1 mile from town ...
Memory Manor is located in a very quiet neighborhood approximately 1 mile from town and 2 blocks from the lake. ...

Goldilocks

42.5
Welcome to Goldilocks, our home away from home on Kelleys Island! We’re imagining our ...
Welcome to Goldilocks, our home away from home on Kelleys Island! We’re imagining our Kelleys Island story is a familiar ...

Tootie’s Place

31
Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can ...
Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can make memorable. Just steps from downtown. ...

Kelleys Island Cottage

32
Thanks for visiting the webpage! The “Kelleys Island Cottage” is a 3 bedroom rental ...
Thanks for visiting the webpage! The “Kelleys Island Cottage” is a 3 bedroom rental home on Kelleys Island. We are ...

KI Sunset Cottage

42
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-sunset-cottage/ KI Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side, looking straight ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-sunset-cottage/ KI Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side, looking straight out towards Put-In-Bay and Perry Monument. ...

South Point Cottage

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/south-point-cottage/ Fully equipped 3 Bedroom, 2 bath Waterfront Cottage is located on Southside ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/south-point-cottage/ Fully equipped 3 Bedroom, 2 bath Waterfront Cottage is located on Southside of Island, just east of Seaway ...
member

Madonna’s Lakefront

21
Madonna’s Lakefront Cottage is a getaway delight located minutes from downtown, on the southeast ...
Madonna’s Lakefront Cottage is a getaway delight located minutes from downtown, on the southeast corner of the island. With beautiful ...
member

MoonGlow Condos

22
Website: bagthemoonkelleys.com/MoonGlow_Condos.php Two fully furnished, air conditioned units for your island vacation are available. ...
Website: bagthemoonkelleys.com/MoonGlow_Condos.php Two fully furnished, air conditioned units for your island vacation are available. Both are within walking distance of ...

An Island Oasis

42.5
Bright and Airy Home with Waterviews Relax and rejuvenate in this exceptional 4 bedroom, ...
Bright and Airy Home with Waterviews Relax and rejuvenate in this exceptional 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home with air conditioning ...

Goldeneye Hideaway

21
Website: Goldeneye Hideaway Pet-friendly 2 Bedroom, 1 bath w/ loft, sleeps a maximum of ...
Website: Goldeneye Hideaway Pet-friendly 2 Bedroom, 1 bath w/ loft, sleeps a maximum of six persons. House is located on ...

The Price is Right

22
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-price-is-right/ The Price is Right – Condo 9D Make us an offer we ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-price-is-right/ The Price is Right – Condo 9D Make us an offer we can’t refuse, and you may get ...

Crafts Marina

Website: craftsonkelleysisland.com Crafts Lakeview Lane is a marina, bait shop and motel on Kelleys ...
Website: craftsonkelleysisland.com Crafts Lakeview Lane is a marina, bait shop and motel on Kelleys Island. We also have cottages by ...

Rent a Kayak

We are located in the Kelley’s Island State Park on the beautiful and sandy ...
We are located in the Kelley’s Island State Park on the beautiful and sandy Public Beach! [xyz-ihs snippet=”Features”] ...

Kelleys Lakeside II

53.5
Coming in 2018 — 1,400 sq. ft. putting green! If you are looking for ...
Coming in 2018 — 1,400 sq. ft. putting green! If you are looking for the ultimate rental home on beautiful ...

Unique Marker

Website: uniquemarker.com WELCOME TO THE UNIQUE MARKER YACHT CLUB!!! Home of the best views ...
Website: uniquemarker.com WELCOME TO THE UNIQUE MARKER YACHT CLUB!!! Home of the best views and the warmest people on the ...

Kiki’s Cottage

32
Website: www.kikiscottage.com Kiki’s Cottage is one of Kelleys island newer cottage rentals. Built in ...
Website: www.kikiscottage.com Kiki’s Cottage is one of Kelleys island newer cottage rentals. Built in 2011 It has many features we ...
member

A Waters Edge Retreat

66
Beautiful Three Story Lakefront Queen Anne Victorian with a Beach & Beach Decks has ...
Beautiful Three Story Lakefront Queen Anne Victorian with a Beach & Beach Decks has amazing unobstructed views in all directions. ...

Dingers Den

32
Dinger’s Den is a three bedroom, two full bath home located on a private ...
Dinger’s Den is a three bedroom, two full bath home located on a private road on the east side of ...
member

Carpe Diem Red

21
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, ...
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, hiking trails, the glacial grooves and ...

Cozy Corner

43
Website: Cozy Corner Our home, equipped with 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms eagerly awaits ...
Website: Cozy Corner Our home, equipped with 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms eagerly awaits your visit to Kelleys Island. Constructed ...

Docks Place

31
Docks Place is a 3 bedroom, 1 bath cottage with central air, kitchen, Living ...
Docks Place is a 3 bedroom, 1 bath cottage with central air, kitchen, Living room with a large yard approximately ...

Zettler’s Lakefront

43
Website: Zettlers Lakefront Home Zettlers Lakefront Home is a charming turn-of-the century, completely renovated ...
Website: Zettlers Lakefront Home Zettlers Lakefront Home is a charming turn-of-the century, completely renovated Queen Anne home located on the ...
member

Caddy Shack Square

“Family Fun Place” located downtown Kelleys Island on Division Street about a block north ...
“Family Fun Place” located downtown Kelleys Island on Division Street about a block north from Water Street / Lakeshore Drive. ...

Blue Heron Retreat

33
Website: https://www.vrbo.com/867624 Blue Heron Retreat is a three bedroom (third bedroom is a loft), ...
Website: https://www.vrbo.com/867624 Blue Heron Retreat is a three bedroom (third bedroom is a loft), three bath luxury condominium on the ...

Vistas al Mar

42.5
This house at 212 McGettigan is located on a fabulous waterfront lot on the ...
This house at 212 McGettigan is located on a fabulous waterfront lot on the east side of the island. Secluded ...

Dreamfinder

22
Enjoy a Dream finder vacation at the Kelleys Island Quarry Condos. Relax on the ...
Enjoy a Dream finder vacation at the Kelleys Island Quarry Condos. Relax on the deck overlooking the tranquility of the ...

Point of View Cottage

32
Website: A Point of View Cottage 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, DirectTV, Large hot tub, ...
Website: A Point of View Cottage 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, DirectTV, Large hot tub, secluded beach and much more… ...

Lake Woods Edge

32
Panoramic, beautiful lake views from all angles! Less than 50 yards from the lake, ...
Panoramic, beautiful lake views from all angles! Less than 50 yards from the lake, Lake Woods Edge is a private, ...

Western Breeze

42
Website: stayonki.com/properties/western-breeze-lakefront-cottage/ Western Breeze Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side (Near ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/western-breeze-lakefront-cottage/ Western Breeze Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side (Near the West Bay Inn). The Lakefront ...

The Guest House

32
“The Guest House” is a 1500 square foot vacation rental located at 309 Harbor ...
“The Guest House” is a 1500 square foot vacation rental located at 309 Harbor Lane. This quiet neighborhood on the ...

Old Stone Place

32.5
Website: oldstoneplace.com The ideal Kelleys Island family vacation rental. Located across from the school ...
Website: oldstoneplace.com The ideal Kelleys Island family vacation rental. Located across from the school and library, Old Stone Place is ...

Whitetail Retreat

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/whitetail-retreat/ 3 bedrooms, 2 Full Bath Vacation Rental located on Private Road near ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/whitetail-retreat/ 3 bedrooms, 2 Full Bath Vacation Rental located on Private Road near Kelleys Island Airport. Downstairs office has ...
member

Sun and Surf

65.5
Website: www.sunandsurfohio.com 4 luxury rooms on the lake with private baths. House is fully ...
Website: www.sunandsurfohio.com 4 luxury rooms on the lake with private baths. House is fully air-conditioned. Direct tv is available in ...
member

Kelleys Lakeside

43
Call now to book for 2018! Nestled on an acre of lakefront property on ...
Call now to book for 2018! Nestled on an acre of lakefront property on beautiful Kelleys Island, this gorgeous four-bedroom/three-full ...