Properties listed in Downtown

Compare properties

Island Delight

22
Island Delight offers a relaxing, easy-living atmosphere for a maximum of four adult occupants, ...
Island Delight offers a relaxing, easy-living atmosphere for a maximum of four adult occupants, with the possible addition of a ...
member

Bag the Moon

Website: www.bagthemoonkelleys.com Bag the Moon is a family-oriented restaurant open for breakfast, lunch and ...
Website: www.bagthemoonkelleys.com Bag the Moon is a family-oriented restaurant open for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Daily specials, as well as ...

Above the Rest

22
Website: stayonki.com/properties/above-the-rest/ Above The Rest, Condo 5F is 2018 Newest Rental. This newly updated ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/above-the-rest/ Above The Rest, Condo 5F is 2018 Newest Rental. This newly updated end unit sleeps a maximum of ...

Goldilocks

42.5
Welcome to Goldilocks, our home away from home on Kelleys Island! We’re imagining our ...
Welcome to Goldilocks, our home away from home on Kelleys Island! We’re imagining our Kelleys Island story is a familiar ...
member

Papa T’s Deckside

Website: www.facebook.com/Papa-Ts-Deckside-241336458698/ A visit to Kelleys Island wouldn’t be complete without a Malt or ...
Website: www.facebook.com/Papa-Ts-Deckside-241336458698/ A visit to Kelleys Island wouldn’t be complete without a Malt or Shake from PapaT’s! Toft’s Hand-dipped & ...

The Upper Deck

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-upper-deck/ The Upper Deck is located in the upstairs unit of Kelleys Island’s ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-upper-deck/ The Upper Deck is located in the upstairs unit of Kelleys Island’s only Downtown Rental Property. This 3 ...

Fun at Kelleys

22
Website: funatkelleys.com You are invited to enjoy the peaceful atmosphere at The Quarry Condominiums ...
Website: funatkelleys.com You are invited to enjoy the peaceful atmosphere at The Quarry Condominiums on beautiful and secluded Kelleys Island. ...
member

The Village Peddler

While the Village Peddler has been a fixture on Kelleys Island for many years, ...
While the Village Peddler has been a fixture on Kelleys Island for many years, ‘The Peddler’ now has a new ...

General Store Carts

Website: kigeneralstore.com Renting a golf cart is the perfect way to cruise around the ...
Website: kigeneralstore.com Renting a golf cart is the perfect way to cruise around the island and see everything Kelleys has ...

North East Passage

22
Lovely 2 Bedroom, 2 Bath condo on the quarry available to rent this season. ...
Lovely 2 Bedroom, 2 Bath condo on the quarry available to rent this season. May 12-14 Weekly rentals during peak ...

Caddy Shack Carts

Website: caddyshacksquare.com Caddy Shack Golf Cart and Bike Rentals Enjoy tooling around the island ...
Website: caddyshacksquare.com Caddy Shack Golf Cart and Bike Rentals Enjoy tooling around the island on “KI Time” in one of ...

The Blue House

62
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-blue-house/ LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION. This 6 bedroom, 2 bathroom home eagerly awaits your ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-blue-house/ LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION. This 6 bedroom, 2 bathroom home eagerly awaits your visit to Kelleys Island. Located in ...

The Price is Right

22
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-price-is-right/ The Price is Right – Condo 9D Make us an offer we ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-price-is-right/ The Price is Right – Condo 9D Make us an offer we can’t refuse, and you may get ...

Uncle Tony’s

22
Website: stayonki.com/properties/uncle-tonys/ Beautifully updated 2 Bedroom, 2 Bath Condo – This 2nd story unit ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/uncle-tonys/ Beautifully updated 2 Bedroom, 2 Bath Condo – This 2nd story unit has slight lake views off the ...
member

Taste by the Lake

Website: www.facebook.com/pages/Taste-by-the-Lake/1648562948705579 We are KI’s gourmet coffee shop. We serve fresh donuts and coffee ...
Website: www.facebook.com/pages/Taste-by-the-Lake/1648562948705579 We are KI’s gourmet coffee shop. We serve fresh donuts and coffee drinks, pastry, prepared food including salads, ...
member

Captain’s Corner

Website: www.kicaptain.com American (Traditional), Breakfast, Greek and Mediterranean, Sandwiches and Steakhouses [xyz-ihs snippet=”Features”] ...
Website: www.kicaptain.com American (Traditional), Breakfast, Greek and Mediterranean, Sandwiches and Steakhouses [xyz-ihs snippet=”Features”] ...

A Break at the Lake

33
Website: stayonki.com/properties/a-break-at-the-lake/ “A Break at The Lake” has 2 Bedrooms and a loft and ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/a-break-at-the-lake/ “A Break at The Lake” has 2 Bedrooms and a loft and 3 full baths. Linens are not ...

Rent a Golf Cart

Rent a golf cart at one of many locations around the island and take ...
Rent a golf cart at one of many locations around the island and take a leisurely tour of the island. ...

Collins Lakeview

22
Our condo provides a spectacular view of Lake Erie from the second floor balcony, ...
Our condo provides a spectacular view of Lake Erie from the second floor balcony, spend time relaxing and feeling the ...

Downtown Flat

22
Website: stayonki.com/properties/downtown-flat/ Downtown Flat is the lower level unit of the “South Side School” ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/downtown-flat/ Downtown Flat is the lower level unit of the “South Side School” which was built in 1853. This ...
member

Campbell’s Condo

22
The condo is tastefully furnished and decorated and is complete with all linens, dishes ...
The condo is tastefully furnished and decorated and is complete with all linens, dishes and paper products. The modern kitchen ...

Play Putt Putt

Website: caddyshacksquare.com/putt-putt/ Enjoy our 18 Hole Old-Fashioned Mini-Golf Course, It’s a Family Affair! [xyz-ihs ...
Website: caddyshacksquare.com/putt-putt/ Enjoy our 18 Hole Old-Fashioned Mini-Golf Course, It’s a Family Affair! [xyz-ihs snippet=”Features”] ...
member

Island Market

Welcome to the Island Market—the oldest and longest-established store on Kelleys Island! The Island ...
Welcome to the Island Market—the oldest and longest-established store on Kelleys Island! The Island Market, located in the heart of ...

Tootie’s Place

31
Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can ...
Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can make memorable. Just steps from downtown. ...
member

Caddy Shack

Website: www.caddyshackki.com Caddy Shack Restaurant and Bar proudly features some of the finest and ...
Website: www.caddyshackki.com Caddy Shack Restaurant and Bar proudly features some of the finest and freshest food on Kelleys Island. While ...

Augie’s Sea Escape

22
Nautically decorated 1st floor unit with 2 bedrooms and 2 baths, a/c and a ...
Nautically decorated 1st floor unit with 2 bedrooms and 2 baths, a/c and a great location in the Quarry Condo ...

Back in Time

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/back-in-time/ LOCATION IS KEY – “BACK IN TIME COTTAGE” is a fully-equipped Historical ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/back-in-time/ LOCATION IS KEY – “BACK IN TIME COTTAGE” is a fully-equipped Historical Island Home located in The Heart ...

Missy Magoos

Website: www.facebook.com/missy.magoo.9883 A new business on Kelleys Island! Featuring old-fashioned candy shop, vintage items, ...
Website: www.facebook.com/missy.magoo.9883 A new business on Kelleys Island! Featuring old-fashioned candy shop, vintage items, artisanal gifts, and toys for all ...

Dreamfinder

22
Enjoy a Dream finder vacation at the Kelleys Island Quarry Condos. Relax on the ...
Enjoy a Dream finder vacation at the Kelleys Island Quarry Condos. Relax on the deck overlooking the tranquility of the ...

Dipper Dan’s Ice Cream

Website: caddyshacksquare.com/dippers-dan-ice-cream-stand/ Serving “Toft’s” Brand hand-dipped Ice Cream, a local favorite. …only the Best ...
Website: caddyshacksquare.com/dippers-dan-ice-cream-stand/ Serving “Toft’s” Brand hand-dipped Ice Cream, a local favorite. …only the Best in all your Favorite Flavors [xyz-ihs ...
member

Kelleys Landing

Kelleys Landing (in the Caddy Shack Square). The same high-quality Gear clothing line is ...
Kelleys Landing (in the Caddy Shack Square). The same high-quality Gear clothing line is available, complemented with new upscale additions. ...

Blue Heron Retreat

33
Website: https://www.vrbo.com/867624 Blue Heron Retreat is a three bedroom (third bedroom is a loft), ...
Website: https://www.vrbo.com/867624 Blue Heron Retreat is a three bedroom (third bedroom is a loft), three bath luxury condominium on the ...
member

Island House

Website: www.facebook.com/kelleysislandhouse The Island House on Kelleys Island is food, friends, spirits, and true ...
Website: www.facebook.com/kelleysislandhouse The Island House on Kelleys Island is food, friends, spirits, and true island ambience mixed into one. Our ...
member

MoonGlow Condos

22
Website: bagthemoonkelleys.com/MoonGlow_Condos.php Two fully furnished, air conditioned units for your island vacation are available. ...
Website: bagthemoonkelleys.com/MoonGlow_Condos.php Two fully furnished, air conditioned units for your island vacation are available. Both are within walking distance of ...
member

The General Store

Website: kigeneralstore.com We are your one-stop shop for all your vacation getaway items and ...
Website: kigeneralstore.com We are your one-stop shop for all your vacation getaway items and last minute needs. Left it at ...
member

Caddy Shack Square

“Family Fun Place” located downtown Kelleys Island on Division Street about a block north ...
“Family Fun Place” located downtown Kelleys Island on Division Street about a block north from Water Street / Lakeshore Drive. ...
member

Island Fudge Shoppe

Located in the historic Fred Elfers building on Division in the downtown area. When ...
Located in the historic Fred Elfers building on Division in the downtown area. When you visit stop in and try ...
member

Dockers

Website: www.facebook.com/Dockers-Waterfront-Bar-and-Restaurant-150324821645829/ Come and sit in our outdoor “dining room” and enjoy the views ...
Website: www.facebook.com/Dockers-Waterfront-Bar-and-Restaurant-150324821645829/ Come and sit in our outdoor “dining room” and enjoy the views of Lake Erie, from Cedar Point ...

Fishing Charter

Websites: Nacho Fish | Captain Park’s Charters Go walleye, perch, and bass fishing off ...
Websites: Nacho Fish | Captain Park’s Charters Go walleye, perch, and bass fishing off the islands with our experienced crews! ...

The Quarry’s Edge

22
Website: stayonki.com/properties/quarrys-edge/ 2 Bedroom, 2 full bath lower level unit has been recently upgraded ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/quarrys-edge/ 2 Bedroom, 2 full bath lower level unit has been recently upgraded and updated! New for 2015 – ...
member

The Casino

Website: www.kelleysislandcasino.com The Casino Restaurant & Marina is located in the heart of downtown ...
Website: www.kelleysislandcasino.com The Casino Restaurant & Marina is located in the heart of downtown Kelleys Island, Ohio at the base ...
member

Chicklet’s Closet

Chicklet’s Closet Located in the former Village Peddler location Chicklet’s Closet features Fresh Produce, ...
Chicklet’s Closet Located in the former Village Peddler location Chicklet’s Closet features Fresh Produce, Roxy, Quicksilver, Reef, Hurley, Crocs, Keen ...
member

Kelleys Cove Condo

22
Thank you for your interest in our condos. We have upgraded our condos and ...
Thank you for your interest in our condos. We have upgraded our condos and made them even more attractive and ...

Portside Marina

Website: portsidemarinaki.com Portside Marina is Kelleys Island’s finest docking and dining destination. Recently rebuilt ...
Website: portsidemarinaki.com Portside Marina is Kelleys Island’s finest docking and dining destination. Recently rebuilt and renovated, it is family owned ...