Properties listed in Kelleys Island

Compare properties

member

Memory Manor

32
Memory Manor is located in a very quiet neighborhood approximately 1 mile from town ...
Memory Manor is located in a very quiet neighborhood approximately 1 mile from town and 2 blocks from the lake. ...

Tootie’s Place

31
Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can ...
Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can make memorable. Just steps from downtown. ...
member

Island House

The Island House on Kelleys Island is food, friends, spirits, and true island ambience ...
The Island House on Kelleys Island is food, friends, spirits, and true island ambience mixed into one. Our culinary team ...
member

Caddy Shack Square

“Family Fun Place” located downtown Kelleys Island on Division Street about a block north ...
“Family Fun Place” located downtown Kelleys Island on Division Street about a block north from Water Street / Lakeshore Drive. ...

Kiki’s Cottage

32
Website: www.kikiscottage.com Kiki’s Cottage is one of Kelleys island newer cottage rentals. Built in ...
Website: www.kikiscottage.com Kiki’s Cottage is one of Kelleys island newer cottage rentals. Built in 2011 It has many features we ...

Augie’s Sea Escape

22
Nautically decorated 1st floor unit with 2 bedrooms and 2 baths, a/c and a ...
Nautically decorated 1st floor unit with 2 bedrooms and 2 baths, a/c and a great location in the Quarry Condo ...
member

The Village Peddler

While the Village Peddler has been a fixture on Kelleys Island for many years, ...
While the Village Peddler has been a fixture on Kelleys Island for many years, ‘The Peddler’ now has a new ...

Sweetbriar Retreat

32
Custom built in 2008, Sweetbriar Retreat is designed for the family who wants to ...
Custom built in 2008, Sweetbriar Retreat is designed for the family who wants to get away from it all and ...
member

West Bay Inn

The West Bay Inn is known for its beautiful views and sunsets, is the ...
The West Bay Inn is known for its beautiful views and sunsets, is the Best “Dock-n-Dine Deal” on Kelleys Island ...
member

Madonna’s Lakefront

21
Madonna’s Lakefront Cottage is a getaway delight located minutes from downtown, on the southeast ...
Madonna’s Lakefront Cottage is a getaway delight located minutes from downtown, on the southeast corner of the island. With beautiful ...
member

Ahoy Condo

22
Comfortably decorated to enjoy your relaxing visit to Kelleys Island. Completely furmished two bedroom, ...
Comfortably decorated to enjoy your relaxing visit to Kelleys Island. Completely furmished two bedroom, two bath condominium. All the comforts ...

Kelleys Mansion

Kelleys Mansion is being privately restored and is located on 211 East Lakeshore Drive. ...
Kelleys Mansion is being privately restored and is located on 211 East Lakeshore Drive. It is not open to the ...

Rent a Bicycle

Bicycle down Lover’s Lane from the State Park…..a wonderful, romantic coast all the way ...
Bicycle down Lover’s Lane from the State Park…..a wonderful, romantic coast all the way to the Lake. Bicycles can be ...

Eagles Nest Inn

Located on the edge of a private preserve, the Eagle’s Nest Inn is very ...
Located on the edge of a private preserve, the Eagle’s Nest Inn is very comfortable, relaxed and pleasant. For outdoor ...
member

Island Market

Welcome to the Island Market—the oldest and longest-established store on Kelleys Island! The Island ...
Welcome to the Island Market—the oldest and longest-established store on Kelleys Island! The Island Market, located in the heart of ...

Buckleys Drydock

44
Come spend your time dry-docked with Buckley (52 lb. Alaskan King Salmon caught by ...
Come spend your time dry-docked with Buckley (52 lb. Alaskan King Salmon caught by the owner) at his luxurious island ...
member

The Inn

42
Website: innki20.wix.com/innofkelleysisland Side wheelers and sailing schooners that once plied our waters have been ...
Website: innki20.wix.com/innofkelleysisland Side wheelers and sailing schooners that once plied our waters have been replaced by freighters and ferry boats. ...
member

Charles Herndon Galleries

Website: www.charlesherndon.com/ In 2000 Chuck Herndon built his first gallery on Kelleys Island, in ...
Website: www.charlesherndon.com/ In 2000 Chuck Herndon built his first gallery on Kelleys Island, in a two-story 48×35 foot building. In ...
member

Crafts Lakeview Lane

11
Each room has two double beds and a private bath, air-conditioning and heat. Linens ...
Each room has two double beds and a private bath, air-conditioning and heat. Linens are provided. There are no cooking ...
member

House on Huntington

44
Charming, serene, and tranquil describes the House on Huntington Lane. A Century home renovated ...
Charming, serene, and tranquil describes the House on Huntington Lane. A Century home renovated and restored to the charm of ...

Quarry Lake Cabin

32
Escape to the Quarry Lake Cabin and ease into island life. This beautiful, newer ...
Escape to the Quarry Lake Cabin and ease into island life. This beautiful, newer home has two bedrooms plus a ...

Toss Horseshoes

Website: www.kelleysislandwineco.com Stop by the winery and throw some shoes will you enjoy a ...
Website: www.kelleysislandwineco.com Stop by the winery and throw some shoes will you enjoy a few glasses. ...
member

Unc’l Dik’s

Travel north on Division St. to Unc’l Dik’s to enjoy a creamy treat from ...
Travel north on Division St. to Unc’l Dik’s to enjoy a creamy treat from Toft’s. As their sign says, “hot ...
member

Vi’s Island Treasures

Vi’s Island Treasures is Kelleys Island’s most unique gift shop, located just to the ...
Vi’s Island Treasures is Kelleys Island’s most unique gift shop, located just to the east of the Kelleys Mansion. The ...

North East Passage

22
Weekly rentals during peak season Open June 26-July 3 July 3-10 August 7-14 and. ...
Weekly rentals during peak season Open June 26-July 3 July 3-10 August 7-14 and. August 21-28. $200 deposit and $1,000 ...
member

Papa T’s Deckside

A visit to Kelleys Island wouldn’t be complete without a Malt or Shake from ...
A visit to Kelleys Island wouldn’t be complete without a Malt or Shake from PapaT’s! Toft’s Hand-dipped & soft serve ...

Fishing Charter

Websites: Nacho Fish | Captain Park’s Charters Go walleye, perch, and bass fishing off ...
Websites: Nacho Fish | Captain Park’s Charters Go walleye, perch, and bass fishing off the islands with our experienced crews! ...

Goldeneye Hideaway

21
Website: Goldeneye Hideaway Pet-friendly 2 Bedroom, 1 bath w/ loft, sleeps a maximum of ...
Website: Goldeneye Hideaway Pet-friendly 2 Bedroom, 1 bath w/ loft, sleeps a maximum of six persons. House is located on ...

Anneliese’s Treasure Chest

Come on in and see us in person from May until the end of ...
Come on in and see us in person from May until the end of October. We are open weekends only ...

Andrews Condo

22
Comfortably decorated to enjoy your relaxing visit to Kelleys Island. Completely furmished two bedroom, ...
Comfortably decorated to enjoy your relaxing visit to Kelleys Island. Completely furmished two bedroom, two bath condominium. All the comforts ...

Playground

We have a playground for the kids! ...
We have a playground for the kids! ...
member

Kelleys Cove Condo

22
Thank you for your interest in our condos. We have upgraded our condos and ...
Thank you for your interest in our condos. We have upgraded our condos and made them even more attractive and ...

Lake Woods Edge

32
Panoramic, beautiful lake views from all angles! Less than 50 yards from the lake, ...
Panoramic, beautiful lake views from all angles! Less than 50 yards from the lake, Lake Woods Edge is a private, ...
member

Hauser House

42
The Hauser House is a 2-story, 4 bedroom home located on the S.W. corner ...
The Hauser House is a 2-story, 4 bedroom home located on the S.W. corner of Division & Bookerman. The home ...

Kelleys Lakeside II

3.5
Opening May 2017! If you are looking for the ultimate rental home on beautiful ...
Opening May 2017! If you are looking for the ultimate rental home on beautiful Kelleys Island, you have found it. ...

Swim at Sandy Beach

Enjoy the Sandy Beach on the North side at the State Park. ...
Enjoy the Sandy Beach on the North side at the State Park. ...
member

Island Fudge Shoppe

Located in the historic Fred Elfers building on Division in the downtown area. When ...
Located in the historic Fred Elfers building on Division in the downtown area. When you visit stop in and try ...

Aunt Jackie’s Holiday

32
Website: Aunt Jackie’s Holiday House This 3 bedroom, 2 bath sleeps 8-10. Two living ...
Website: Aunt Jackie’s Holiday House This 3 bedroom, 2 bath sleeps 8-10. Two living rooms, one on each floor. Upstairs ...

Scuba Diving

Website: http://www.eriewrecks.com/shipwrecks/kelleys/kelleys.html Come and explore the heritage in Lake Erie’s western basin. Enjoy Kelleys ...
Website: http://www.eriewrecks.com/shipwrecks/kelleys/kelleys.html Come and explore the heritage in Lake Erie’s western basin. Enjoy Kelleys Island summer’s diving the multitude of ...
member

A Waters Edge Retreat

66
Beautiful Three Story Lakefront Queen Anne Victorian with a Beach & Beach Decks has ...
Beautiful Three Story Lakefront Queen Anne Victorian with a Beach & Beach Decks has amazing unobstructed views in all directions. ...
member

The Village Pump

The Village Pump has been the destination watering hole for boaters and visitors alike ...
The Village Pump has been the destination watering hole for boaters and visitors alike since 1983. Specialties include the ‘famous’ ...
member

Chicklet’s Closet

Chicklet’s Closet Located in the former Village Peddler location Chicklet’s Closet features Fresh Produce, ...
Chicklet’s Closet Located in the former Village Peddler location Chicklet’s Closet features Fresh Produce, Roxy, Quicksilver, Reef, Hurley, Crocs, Keen ...

Kiki’s Cabin

32
Website: www.kikiscabin.com Cabin Amenities • 2 bedrooms with KING size memory foam mattresses. Oversized ...
Website: www.kikiscabin.com Cabin Amenities • 2 bedrooms with KING size memory foam mattresses. Oversized Loft area with 2 KING sized ...

Vistas al Mar

42.5
This house at 212 McGettigan is located on a fabulous waterfront lot on the ...
This house at 212 McGettigan is located on a fabulous waterfront lot on the east side of the island. Secluded ...
member

Kelleys Landing

(in the former Kelleys Cove location). The same high quality Gear clothing line is ...
(in the former Kelleys Cove location). The same high quality Gear clothing line is available, complimented with a new upscale ...

Blue Heron Retreat

33
Website: https://www.vrbo.com/867624 Blue Heron Retreat is a three bedroom (third bedroom is a loft), ...
Website: https://www.vrbo.com/867624 Blue Heron Retreat is a three bedroom (third bedroom is a loft), three bath luxury condominium on the ...

Summer Wind

31.5
Private cottage comfortably decorated with a cathedral ceiling and bright, open floor plan. The ...
Private cottage comfortably decorated with a cathedral ceiling and bright, open floor plan. The home is located on a quiet, ...
member

Lodge on the Lake

42
This is a house rental only. Come and relax in a lakefront paradise. Lake ...
This is a house rental only. Come and relax in a lakefront paradise. Lake views from all bedrooms and sunroom. ...
member

Carpe Diem White

21
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, ...
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, hiking trails, the glacial grooves and ...
member

Campbell’s Condo

22
The condo is tastefully furnished and decorated and is complete with all linens, dishes ...
The condo is tastefully furnished and decorated and is complete with all linens, dishes and paper products. The modern kitchen ...

Island Delight

22
Island Delight offers a relaxing, easy-living atmosphere for a maximum of four adult occupants, ...
Island Delight offers a relaxing, easy-living atmosphere for a maximum of four adult occupants, with the possible addition of a ...

House on the Lake

31.5
At House on the Lake, it is just you and the lake. House on ...
At House on the Lake, it is just you and the lake. House on the Lake is a three bedroom ...
member

KI Cantina

Website: www.facebook.com/KIcantina/ A Bar Specializing in house-made margaritas. ...
Website: www.facebook.com/KIcantina/ A Bar Specializing in house-made margaritas. ...
member

The Casino

The Casino Restaurant & Marina is located in the heart of downtown Kelleys Island, ...
The Casino Restaurant & Marina is located in the heart of downtown Kelleys Island, Ohio at the base of Division ...

Dingers Den

32
Dinger’s Den is a three bedroom, two full bath home located on a private ...
Dinger’s Den is a three bedroom, two full bath home located on a private road on the east side of ...
member

Sandy Beach House

42.5
Lovingly restored century home with four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths promises to make your ...
Lovingly restored century home with four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths promises to make your island stay a memorable experience. Sandy ...
member

The Cliff House

42
The Cliff House is tucked away in a secluded central part of the island. ...
The Cliff House is tucked away in a secluded central part of the island. With an acre of land, the ...

Fishing

Website: www.oh.wildlifelicense.com/index_hf.php Many places around the island to fish, with a proper license, ...
Website: www.oh.wildlifelicense.com/index_hf.php Many places around the island to fish, with a proper license, ...

Glacial Grooves

A National Natural Landmark, the Glacial Grooves on the north side of Kelleys Island ...
A National Natural Landmark, the Glacial Grooves on the north side of Kelleys Island are the largest easily accessible such ...

Cedar Cottage

31
Website: https://www.vrbo.com/668325 The Cedar Cottage is the perfect place to stay for your getaway ...
Website: https://www.vrbo.com/668325 The Cedar Cottage is the perfect place to stay for your getaway to Kelleys Island, Ohio. This beautiful ...