Default Order Highest Rated Most Reviewed Newest Listings Oldest Listings Featured Most Views Random Shopping Parsonage Resale Shop 224 Division St., Kelleys Island Ohio 43438 Rentals Above The Rest 111 W Lakeshore Dr., Kelleys Island, OH 43438 Eat & Drink Caddy Shack 115 Division St., Kelleys Island, OH 43438 What To Do Beer Tasting 504 W Lakeshore Dr. Rentals Goldilocks 111 W Lakeshore Dr., Kelleys Island, OH 43438 Services, Shopping Monarch Butterfly Box 604 Division St. 1 23