Homes and Cottages

Compare Listings

Cottages
Rentals
member

Crafts Lakeview Lane

Website: craftsonkelleysisland.com Cottage #1: Lakefront, two bedrooms, with three double beds, one single bed and [more]
Website: craftsonkelleysisland.com Cottage #1: Lakefront, two bedrooms, with three double beds, one single bed and [more]

The Getaway

Website: www.leisureworldvacationrentals.com Welcome to The Getaway on Kelleys Island The 1,450 square feet of The [more]
Website: www.leisureworldvacationrentals.com Welcome to The Getaway on Kelleys Island The 1,450 square feet of The [more]

Changes In Latitude KI, LLC

This lakefront 3 bedroom/2 full bath home is newly remodeled and located just a half mile from downtown Kelleys Isl [more]
This lakefront 3 bedroom/2 full bath home is newly remodeled and located just a half mile from downtown Kelleys Isl [more]
Porch
Rentals

Point of View Cottage

Website: A Point of View Cottage 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, DirectTV, Large hot tub, secluded beach and much more…
Website: A Point of View Cottage 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, DirectTV, Large hot tub, secluded beach and much more…
Whitetail Retreat
Rentals

Whitetail Retreat

Website: stayonki.com/properties/whitetail-retreat/ 3 bedrooms, 2 Full Bath Vacation Rental located on Private Road [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/whitetail-retreat/ 3 bedrooms, 2 Full Bath Vacation Rental located on Private Road [more]

The Other House

Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-other-house/ Step Back in Time and Enjoy This 5 bedroom, 2 Full bath lakefront [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-other-house/ Step Back in Time and Enjoy This 5 bedroom, 2 Full bath lakefront [more]

Cedar Cottage

Website: https://www.vrbo.com/668325 The Cedar Cottage is the perfect place to stay for your getaway to Kelleys Isl [more]
Website: https://www.vrbo.com/668325 The Cedar Cottage is the perfect place to stay for your getaway to Kelleys Isl [more]

301 Ski Lodge – Log Cabin

Website: stayonki.com/properties/301ski-lodge-kelleys-island-log-cabin/ Beautifully Appointed 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath Kel [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/301ski-lodge-kelleys-island-log-cabin/ Beautifully Appointed 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath Kel [more]
Rentals
member

Carpe Diem Red

We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, hiking trails, the glacial groove [more]
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, hiking trails, the glacial groove [more]
The Cliff House
Rentals
member

The Cliff House

The Cliff House is tucked away in a secluded central part of the island. With an acre of land, the backyard gives v [more]
The Cliff House is tucked away in a secluded central part of the island. With an acre of land, the backyard gives v [more]
Rentals

Sweetbriar Retreat

Custom built in 2008, Sweetbriar Retreat is designed for the family who wants to get away from it all and relax on [more]
Custom built in 2008, Sweetbriar Retreat is designed for the family who wants to get away from it all and relax on [more]
Lookout Point Cottage
Rentals

Lookout Point Cottage

Website: stayonki.com/properties/lookout-point-cottage/ Newly updated 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath secluded lakeview vacation [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/lookout-point-cottage/ Newly updated 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath secluded lakeview vacation [more]

KI Hideaway

Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-hideaway/ This home is equipped with 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. This home is s [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-hideaway/ This home is equipped with 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. This home is s [more]

Annalee’s Cottage

The perfect vacation spot! Step into a time gone by – wicker chairs on the porch, gentle lake breezes, warm s [more]
The perfect vacation spot! Step into a time gone by – wicker chairs on the porch, gentle lake breezes, warm s [more]

Kiki’s Cabin

Website: www.kikiscabin.com Cabin Amenities • 2 bedrooms with KING size memory foam mattresses. Oversized Loft area [more]
Website: www.kikiscabin.com Cabin Amenities • 2 bedrooms with KING size memory foam mattresses. Oversized Loft area [more]

The Blue House

Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-blue-house/ LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION. This 6 bedroom, 2 bathroom home eage [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-blue-house/ LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION. This 6 bedroom, 2 bathroom home eage [more]

Cottage on Sunset

Comfortable and private, this is your home away from home on Kelleys Island. • 2 Bedrooms that sleep 6 very comfort [more]
Comfortable and private, this is your home away from home on Kelleys Island. • 2 Bedrooms that sleep 6 very comfort [more]
Front
Rentals

Vistas al Mar

This house at 212 McGettigan is located on a fabulous waterfront lot on the east side of the island. Secluded and p [more]
This house at 212 McGettigan is located on a fabulous waterfront lot on the east side of the island. Secluded and p [more]
42.5full info
Front Deck
Rentals

Docks Place

Docks Place is a 3 bedroom, 1 bath cottage with central air, kitchen, Living room with a large yard approximately 1 [more]
Docks Place is a 3 bedroom, 1 bath cottage with central air, kitchen, Living room with a large yard approximately 1 [more]
Interior
Rentals

Goldeneye Hideaway

Website: Goldeneye Hideaway Pet-friendly 2 Bedroom, 1 bath w/ loft, sleeps a maximum of six persons. House is locat [more]
Website: Goldeneye Hideaway Pet-friendly 2 Bedroom, 1 bath w/ loft, sleeps a maximum of six persons. House is locat [more]
Front
Rentals
member

Kelleys Lake House

Take a deep breath and relax. We have you covered. Imagine a beach fire on a starry night. You’re almost ther [more]
Take a deep breath and relax. We have you covered. Imagine a beach fire on a starry night. You’re almost ther [more]

Fawn Memories

Website: stayonki.com/properties/fawn-memories/ This Newer 2 Bedroom, 1 Bath Ranch Pet-friendly rental has North Ba [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/fawn-memories/ This Newer 2 Bedroom, 1 Bath Ranch Pet-friendly rental has North Ba [more]
Kelleys Lakeside 2
Rentals

Kelleys Lakeside II

If you are looking for the ultimate rental home on beautiful Kelleys Island, you have found it. This 5 bedroom R [more]
If you are looking for the ultimate rental home on beautiful Kelleys Island, you have found it. This 5 bedroom R [more]
53.5full info
House on the Lake
Rentals

House on the Lake

At House on the Lake, it is just you and the lake. House on the Lake is a three bedroom plus loft home located on a [more]
At House on the Lake, it is just you and the lake. House on the Lake is a three bedroom plus loft home located on a [more]
31.5full info

Quarry Lake Cabin

Escape to the Quarry Lake Cabin and ease into island life. This beautiful, newer home has two bedrooms plus a spaci [more]
Escape to the Quarry Lake Cabin and ease into island life. This beautiful, newer home has two bedrooms plus a spaci [more]

Downtown Flat

Website: stayonki.com/properties/downtown-flat/ Downtown Flat is the lower level unit of the “South Side Scho [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/downtown-flat/ Downtown Flat is the lower level unit of the “South Side Scho [more]
Front
Rentals

Island Time House

Newer 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch style home with vaulted ceilings and open floor plan. Great for entertaining and larg [more]
Newer 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch style home with vaulted ceilings and open floor plan. Great for entertaining and larg [more]

Kiki’s Cottage

Website: www.kikiscottage.com Kiki’s Cottage is one of Kelleys island newer cottage rentals. Built in 2011 It [more]
Website: www.kikiscottage.com Kiki’s Cottage is one of Kelleys island newer cottage rentals. Built in 2011 It [more]
Rentals
member

Carpe Diem White

We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, hiking trails, the glacial groove [more]
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, hiking trails, the glacial groove [more]

The Farm House

Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-farm-house/ Step Back in Time and Relax and Enjoy Kelleys Island For all it ha [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-farm-house/ Step Back in Time and Relax and Enjoy Kelleys Island For all it ha [more]

Cozy Corner

Website: Cozy Corner Our home, equipped with 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms eagerly awaits your visit to Kelleys Island [more]
Website: Cozy Corner Our home, equipped with 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms eagerly awaits your visit to Kelleys Island [more]
KI Sunset Cottage
Rentals

KI Sunset Cottage

Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-sunset-cottage/ KI Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-sunset-cottage/ KI Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side [more]
Front
Rentals
member

Sandy Beach House

Lovingly restored century home with four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths promises to make your island stay a memo [more]
Lovingly restored century home with four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths promises to make your island stay a memo [more]
42.5full info
Rentals
member

Lodge on the Lake

This is a house rental only. Come and relax in a lakefront paradise. Lake views from all bedrooms and sunroom. Enjo [more]
This is a house rental only. Come and relax in a lakefront paradise. Lake views from all bedrooms and sunroom. Enjo [more]

Kiki’s Villa

Website: kikisvilla.com *** Brand New Just built rental 2019*** Kikis Villa is a brand new resort rental built with [more]
Website: kikisvilla.com *** Brand New Just built rental 2019*** Kikis Villa is a brand new resort rental built with [more]
43.5full info
Madonnas
Rentals
member

Madonna’s Lakefront

Madonna’s Lakefront Cottage is a getaway delight located minutes from downtown, on the southeast corner of th [more]
Madonna’s Lakefront Cottage is a getaway delight located minutes from downtown, on the southeast corner of th [more]
Front
Rentals
member

Hauser House

The Hauser House is a 2-story, 4 bedroom home located on the S.W. corner of Division & Bookerman. The home is o [more]
The Hauser House is a 2-story, 4 bedroom home located on the S.W. corner of Division & Bookerman. The home is o [more]

Sunset View Cottages

Lakefront furnished (no linens provided). Two cottages sleep six people each and one large cottage that sleeps twel [more]
Lakefront furnished (no linens provided). Two cottages sleep six people each and one large cottage that sleeps twel [more]
Cottage Front
Rentals
member

Memory Manor

Memory Manor is located in a very quiet neighborhood approximately 1 mile from town and 2 blocks from the lake. We [more]
Memory Manor is located in a very quiet neighborhood approximately 1 mile from town and 2 blocks from the lake. We [more]
BK's Beach House
Rentals
member

BKs Beach House

Website: stayonki.com/properties/bks-beach-house/ This Beach House is Brand New! Over 100 feet of sand beach! – 3 B [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/bks-beach-house/ This Beach House is Brand New! Over 100 feet of sand beach! – 3 B [more]
10
KI Cape Cod
Rentals

KI Cape Cod

Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-cape-cod/ This home is equipped with 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Our home [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-cape-cod/ This home is equipped with 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Our home [more]
Deck Side
Rentals
member

Kelleys Lakeside

Call now to book for 2018! Nestled on an acre of lakefront property on beautiful Kelleys Island, this gorgeous four [more]
Call now to book for 2018! Nestled on an acre of lakefront property on beautiful Kelleys Island, this gorgeous four [more]

Tootie’s Place

Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can make memorable. Just s [more]
Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can make memorable. Just s [more]
Front Porch
Rentals

201 – The Lakeshore

MILLION DOLLAR LAKE VIEW! Beautifully Updated Home On The South Shore Gorgeous 4 bedroom, two bath home on the sout [more]
MILLION DOLLAR LAKE VIEW! Beautifully Updated Home On The South Shore Gorgeous 4 bedroom, two bath home on the sout [more]

Kelleys Island Cottage

Thanks for visiting the webpage! The “Kelleys Island Cottage” is a 3 bedroom rental home on Kelleys Isl [more]
Thanks for visiting the webpage! The “Kelleys Island Cottage” is a 3 bedroom rental home on Kelleys Isl [more]

The Great Escape

A small refurbished cottage with old island charm and new carpet and kitchen amenities. Native stone bathroom and u [more]
A small refurbished cottage with old island charm and new carpet and kitchen amenities. Native stone bathroom and u [more]

The Upper Deck

Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-upper-deck/ The Upper Deck is located in the upstairs unit of Kelleys Island’s [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-upper-deck/ The Upper Deck is located in the upstairs unit of Kelleys Island’s [more]

South Point Cottage

Website: stayonki.com/properties/south-point-cottage/ Fully equipped 3 Bedroom, 2 bath Waterfront Cottage is locate [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/south-point-cottage/ Fully equipped 3 Bedroom, 2 bath Waterfront Cottage is locate [more]

Andy’s Place

Website: www.leisureworldvacationrentals.com Awaiting your arrival is a two bedroom, two bath Lake Erie vacation re [more]
Website: www.leisureworldvacationrentals.com Awaiting your arrival is a two bedroom, two bath Lake Erie vacation re [more]
Western Breeze
Rentals

Western Breeze

Website: stayonki.com/properties/western-breeze-lakefront-cottage/ Western Breeze Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys I [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/western-breeze-lakefront-cottage/ Western Breeze Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys I [more]
Porch
Rentals
member

Pleasant View

Pleasant View Cottages has six weekly rentals on beautiful Lake Erie. With amazing views of the sunset and mainland [more]
Pleasant View Cottages has six weekly rentals on beautiful Lake Erie. With amazing views of the sunset and mainland [more]
Sun and Surf
Rentals
member

Sun and Surf

Website: www.sunandsurfohio.com 4 luxury rooms on the lake with private baths. House is fully air-conditioned. Dire [more]
Website: www.sunandsurfohio.com 4 luxury rooms on the lake with private baths. House is fully air-conditioned. Dire [more]
65.5full info

A Shore Thing

Website: stayonki.com/properties/a-shore-thing/ Fully equipped 2 Bedroom with Loft and one bath Waterfront Cottage [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/a-shore-thing/ Fully equipped 2 Bedroom with Loft and one bath Waterfront Cottage [more]

Casa Del Sol

Casa Del Sol is a recently built Cape Cod situated at the end of a cul de sac on a private street. Wake up to a lak [more]
Casa Del Sol is a recently built Cape Cod situated at the end of a cul de sac on a private street. Wake up to a lak [more]
Morning Glory
Rentals

Morning Glory

Offering the charm of a restored century home and a long stretch of private beach Morning Glory is able to offer he [more]
Offering the charm of a restored century home and a long stretch of private beach Morning Glory is able to offer he [more]

The Barn

Unique new construction Kelleys Island rental – The Barn sleeps six, two bedrooms with one queen size bed and [more]
Unique new construction Kelleys Island rental – The Barn sleeps six, two bedrooms with one queen size bed and [more]
Front
Rentals

Old Stone Place

Website: oldstoneplace.com The ideal Kelleys Island family vacation rental. Located across from the school and libr [more]
Website: oldstoneplace.com The ideal Kelleys Island family vacation rental. Located across from the school and libr [more]
32.5full info
Rentals

Buckleys Drydock

Buckleys Drydock offers a modern, multilevel, executive-style house with room for entertaining plenty of friends an [more]
Buckleys Drydock offers a modern, multilevel, executive-style house with room for entertaining plenty of friends an [more]
Decked Out
Rentals

Decked Out

Website: stayonki.com/properties/decked-out/ **New Rental in 2019!** Updated Pictures coming in the spring! Welcome [more]
Website: stayonki.com/properties/decked-out/ **New Rental in 2019!** Updated Pictures coming in the spring! Welcome [more]
43.5full info

Compare Listings